All Posts

Questions Mount Over an Investigation of Oil Futures Trades

In April of this year, I wrote in BriberyMatters about the corruption risks of the new generation of online prediction markets. In that same piece, I touched on a separate, but related, issue that is back in the headlines: suspicious oil futures trades tied to the war in Iran.

To recap, shortly before President Trump announced he was postponing strikes on Iran’s energy infrastructure on March 23, traders wagered more than $500 million that oil prices would fall. On April 7, a nearly $1 billion trade was timed to a ceasefire announcement. In response, on April 9, Senators Sheldon Whitehouse and Elizabeth Warren urged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to investigate. Other senators and House members later added their voices to that call. The CFTC opened a probe shortly afterwards, and further trades were made on April 17 and April 21. In May, the Justice Department was reported to be investigating these trades in a probe led by the Southern District of New York.

According to the Wall Street Journal, White House staffers were cautioned against betting with nonpublic information after the first trades in March. Then at the end of that month, CFTC Director of Enforcement David I. Miller told an audience at NYU Law School that the Division of Enforcement would prioritize, among other issues, “insider trading… [and] market manipulation (particularly in the energy markets).” Indeed, when a White House teleprompter operator was revealed to have made over $100,000 on Kalshi between December 2025 and February 2026 using his knowledge of the President’s speeches, he was placed on unpaid leave and eventually ordered by the CFTC to pay $172,000 and barred from trading for three years. But those wagers were a pittance compared to the oil futures trades, together worth over $2.6 billion.

What became of the CFTC investigation? In October, we began to get answers. As is standard procedure, analysts in the CFTC’s Division of Market Oversight referred the trades to the Division of Enforcement. Then, as Bloomberg recently revealed, a newly hired senior adviser to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig told a supervisor at the oversight division to retract the referral and took over the analysis himself. CFTC Director of Enforcement Miller has since said the investigation remains open, and it was additionally reported  that a CFTC official stated that “because the original findings were US-focused… there should be a more comprehensive review of markets internationally.” 

The CFTC is reportedly stretched thin, with staffing down 22 percent, which has hampered its ability to oversee markets. Reuters has described a sharp dip in enforcement actions since January 2025. Against that backdrop, Senator Warren has asked the Government Accountability Office (GAO) to examine whether the cuts have compromised the CFTC’s enforcement capacity. In response to the developments in the oil futures probe, she issued a statement calling for Chairman Selig and his adviser to “answer to Congress about the latest status of the agency’s investigations and potential enforcement actions.”

Despite the insistence by the CFTC that its investigation remains open, the situation has nonetheless raised concerns about transparency and accountability, given the involvement of an adviser to a political appointee. Moreover, Chairman Selig is the sole sitting member of a normally five-member, bipartisan Commission, leaving the agency more exposed to perceptions of politicization. Trades such as these, which appear to anticipate decisions at the highest levels of government, call for the utmost independence of the inquiry and of the official overseeing the matter. It will be important to watch where the CFTC investigation goes now, and what comes of the earlier reports of DOJ involvement.

‍

Marc Schleifer
Director of Development and Partnerships, Center for International Private Enterprise
Share

More BriberyMatters Posts

Stay Informed

Subscribe to BriberyMatters

Subscribe to receive the latest BriberyMatters blog posts straight to your inbox!
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.